 |
| Stephanie Woodward |
by Stephanie Woodward (Shared on National Right to Life): Having been born with a physical disability, I am all too familiar with the overwhelming number of people who feel that decisions should be made for me, not by me. I know the tactics used to coerce disabled people into doing what someone else thinks is best because they’ve been used on me. I am well aware of the “ableist” notions that society holds – that having a disability is a tragedy, that we’re a waste of resources and a burden on society, and that we’re “brave” to live with our disabilities (which essentially means that most people would rather die than be “brave” and live with a disability like me).
We’re often regarded as incapable of making our own decisions and unworthy of respect. However, when one disabled person announces they want to die,
they’re lauded in the press and on social media. Sara Myers, for example, has Lou Gehrig’s disease and has received a slew of media attention for wanting assisted suicide because she began to experience disability.
Media focused on Myers’s use of a wheelchair and her need for assistance in showering and toileting to demonstrate why assisted suicide should be available to her. For full disclosure, I use a wheelchair and have needed assistance with both showering and toileting in my life, and I expect I’ll need more assistance as I age. I take it very personally when media and society lists these as valid reasons to want to die.
With all of these negative stereotypes and stigmas against disabled people, combined with the praise a disabled person receives when they announce that they want to die, nothing scares me more than the legalization of assisted suicide. (
David M. Rubin column here.)
Legalized assisted suicide has a disproportionate impact on disabled people. While everyone else receives suicide prevention, people with disabilities and certain illnesses and old people will receive a fast pass because our lives are viewed as less worthy.
Current legislation proposed in New York to legalize assisted suicide not only has no realistic way of protecting from mistake, coercion or abuse, but also lists no reporting requirements. This means that any doctor could prescribe a lethal dose and any person could administer that dose to kill a person, with medical confidentiality preventing any oversight. No independent witness is required during the death of an individual, so there’s no way to ensure that the individual administered the lethal dose himself or herself. In a world where abuse of people with disabilities and seniors is rampant, this alone is cause for concern.
For example, an adult child of an ill 80-year-old woman could accompany her mother to the doctor to obtain the lethal dose, and then administer it without her mother’s consent.
Situations like this have already happened.
Kate Cheney, an 85-year-old woman with early dementia, was brought to her doctor by her daughter to obtain a prescription for the lethal dose in Oregon where assisted suicide is legal. The doctor refused to write the prescription. Unfortunately, that did not prevent Ms. Cheney’s death. Instead, Ms. Cheney’s managed care provider found a different doctor to prescribe the lethal dose.
This second doctor had Ms. Cheney undergo a psychiatric exam and found that Ms. Cheney lacked the capacity to make this decision, so the lethal dose was, again, not prescribed. Cheney’s daughter became very angry and demanded that her mother undergo another evaluation. This psychologist deemed Cheney competent, but noted that Ms. Cheney’s “choices may be influenced by her family’s wishes and her daughter, Erika, may be somewhat coercive.” Soon thereafter Ms. Cheney took the lethal dose and died.
My concerns about assisted death are shared widely throughout the disability community. In fact, every major disability rights organization that has taken a stance on assisted suicide opposes its legalization. Our concerns extend further than abuse.
As I mentioned, disabled people frequently encounter members of society who believe that they know what is best for us. The medical community is one of the biggest offenders. The medical community has historically encouraged parents not to have or raise their disabled children, has prevented disabled people from reproducing by forcibly sterilizing us without our consent, and has forced us into nursing facilities and other institutions simply because of our disabilities. To have this community in charge of deciding who can access assisted suicide is incredibly troubling.
In recent years, plenty of medical professionals have deemed that assisted suicide is appropriate solely if a person is disabled. For example, according to the New England Journal of Medicine, most of Dr. Jack Kevorkian’s victims were not terminally ill, they simply had disabilities. Furthermore, the top reasons given for wanting assisted suicide are not pain or fear of future pain, but feeling like a “burden on others,” experiencing a “loss of autonomy,” or a “loss of dignity.” These factors are all disability related, as disabled people are often made to feel like burdens because we need assistance, which also contributes to the perceived loss of autonomy and dignity.
I, along with my allies in the disability community, urge all New Yorkers to understand that assisted suicide is not a “right” to be glorified, but a double standard that is lethal to communities that are already marginalized, oppressed and abused. We deserve the same suicide prevention that nondisabled people enjoy, because despite the widespread belief otherwise, I assure you, our lives are worth living.
Stephanie Woodward is a graduate of Syracuse University College of Law and is the director of advocacy at the Center for Disability Rights in Rochester.
Tags: Assisted Suicide, disabled people, Stephanie Woodward To share or post to your site, click on "Post Link". Please mention / link to the Greater Fitchburg For Life. Thanks!
According to CNN legal analyst Sunny Hostin, conservative “rhetoric” “tossed fuel” onto the fire that is the abortion debate. The journalist appeared on The View, Monday, and demanded Republicans be held accountable in the wake of a Colorado Planned Parenthood shooting last week. Read More 
More often lately it seems that people who do the right thing are the ones facing criticism and rejection. This week that person is pro-life athlete Tim Tebow. CBS Tampa Bay reports that Tebow’s girlfriend, the former Miss USA Olivia Culpo, broke up with him because he is saving sex until marriage. Read More 
Presidential candidate Hillary Clinton was quick to exploit a shooting in Colorado Springs even before police have apprehend the gunman responsible for shooting multiple police officers and civilians. Read More 
A Missouri Planned Parenthood stopped doing abortions Monday, leaving just one abortion clinic left in the whole state. The move came after Dr. Colleen McNicholas, who did abortions at the Planned Parenthood clinic in Columbia, lost her “refer and follow” hospital admitting privileges at the University of Missouri Health Care, according to the Columbia Tribune. read more 
The popular television show “Scandal” on ABC has pro-life people up in arms about the brash, pro-abortion messaging of its latest show. The Nov. 19 episode took on Congressional efforts to de-fund Planned Parenthood and glorified main character Olivia Pope’s abortion to the tune of “Silent Night.” The episode was a sickening hour-long “advertisement for Planned Parenthood,” Alexa Moutevelis wrote for Newsbusters. Read More 
Hillary Clinton wants the U.S. to start paying for women to abort their babies around the world. The pro-abortion Democratic presidential candidate told an Iowa town hall group Sunday that she wants the U.S. to get around a law baring U.S. foreign aid for abortion, according to CNN. Read More 
ABC’s “Scandal” has everyone talking about the brash, pro-abortion messaging of its latest show. The Nov. 19 episode took on Congressional efforts to de-fund Planned Parenthood and glorified main character Olivia Pope’s abortion to the tune of “Silent Night.” The episode was a sickening hour-long “advertisement for Planned Parenthood,” Alexa Moutevelis wrote for Newsbusters. Read More 
The Planned Parenthood abortion business has filed a lawsuit against the state of Texas, which yanked its taxpayer funding after it was caught selling aborted babies and their body parts. Read More
Ireland’s doctors will be feeling left out in the cold after reading today’s open letter published by Amnesty International. The letter, which calls for further liberalization of Ireland’s abortion laws, makes no mention of the fact that Ireland continues to be a world leader in the area of maternal health. Instead, by claiming that the criminalization of abortion prevents healthcare providers from delivering care to their patients, it offers a very misleading message about the current standard of care offered to pregnant women in Ireland. Read More
A new United Nations document is demanding that conservative Poland makes abortion easily available to young girls. The document, issued in October by the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child, pushes the pro-life Catholic country to “make the conditions for abortion less restrictive and, in relation to adolescent girls, to reflect the right of the child to express her views and the best interests of the child.” Read More
Planned Parenthood is looking for people to thank its staff for killing babies in abortions, so it took to twitter to get people to submit one-word responses to what it goes — hoping to generate a word cloud of positive emotions and experiences to give to its staff and employees. But the pro-life responses people submitted on Twitter were priceless. They paint a very real picture of what the Planned Parenhood abortion business is really about. Read More 
Abortion should be a top issue for Catholic voters in 2016, the U.S. Catholic bishops emphasized Tuesday. The bishops approved a new guide for voters called “Faithful Citizenship,” which stresses the moral importance of voting for candidates with pro-life and pro-family values, according to the Catholic Herald. Read More 
During a Congressional hearing, Attorney General Loretta Lynch confirmed what pro-life organizations suspected in the wake of the scandal involving Planned Parenthood selling aborted babies and their body pats: The head of the Obama administration’s Justice Department hasn’t even bothered to review the videos for any potential violations of federal law. Read More 
The Planned Parenthood abortion business announced today that it plans to spend $20 million to elect pro-abortion Hillary Clinton president and take over Congress. This comes after the abortion giant has been caught up in a massive scandal involving its sales of aborted babies and their body parts. Read More 
If you’ve heard rumors from the media or elsewhere that Senate Republicans are backing down on what would be a third vote in recent months to de-fund the Planned Parenthood abortion business, don’t buy into them. Top Senate Republican leaders said today that, after the Thanksgiving holiday, they are bringing a third bill to the Senate floor to de-fund Planned Parenthood — and Senate Democrats can’t filibuster this one. Read More 
The Supreme Court has refused to take a case against the Obama administration, which faced a lawsuit after it defended the secrecy of a $1 million grant to the New Hampshire affiliate of the Planned Parenthood abortion business in 2011. The abortion giant is getting new national attention after it was caught selling aborted babies and body parts from aborted babies. Read More 
Planned Parenthood has been caught selling the bodies of aborted babies and their body parts. Now, the abortion business has been caught illegally dumping the bodies of aborted babies in a public landfill. As LifeNews reported last week, three South Carolina abortion clinics could face major fines for dumping aborted babies’ bodies into landfills, according to the state Department of Health and Environmental Control. Read More
Liberal, pro-abortion journalist Katie Couric on Tuesday interviewed the President of Planned Parenthood and worried about how “tough” pro-life supporters were making things for the organization. Couric snidely noted, “While Planned Parenthood says that abortions account for just three percent of its clinical work, opponents won’t be happy until that number is zero.” Read More 
Dr. Bill Smith, Editor: My heart goes out to the people of Paris and especially to the families who's family members were murdered or are in emergency care. As you pray for these families and for the leadership of Paris and even our own country, please consider sharing the following image on your social media.
Behind closed doors, abortion advocates are admitting the truth: Abortion is the violent killing of a human life. A undercover video recorded by the Center for Medical Progress and leaked by the website GotNews.com captures a Planned Parenthood official admitting that pro-lifers are right about abortion. The video shows panelists discussing abortion at a National Abortion Federation conference in April of 2014. Read More
Police are investigating a tragic case in Indianapolis where a pregnant, young pastor’s wife was shot in their home. Sadly, state law does not provide for justice for the couple’s unborn baby. Amanda Blackburn, 28, and her 12-week unborn child died from a gunshot wound after what police believe was an attempted burglary around 8:30 a.m. Tuesday, according to ABC News. Read More 
Republican presidential candidate Mike Huckabee minced no words last week in an address to the the National Religious Liberties Conference. There, he questioned how Americans can expect God to bless America when the nation has aborted almost 60 million unborn babies. Read More 
Brian Ingalls is a regular outside the Planned Parenthood abortion facility in Portland, Maine. But now, the state of Maine is taking legal action against the young pro-lifer, accusing him of “disrupting health care services,” The Washington Times Reports. Read More 
Hollywood just can’t seem to stop promoting abortion. This week, Hollywood star Reese Witherspoon used her spotlight to defend Planned Parenthood, the abortion business caught harvesting and trafficking aborted babies’ body parts in an undercover investigation. “No mother in the world wants her daughter to have fewer rights than she did,” Witherspoon said, referring to the Planned Parenthood scandal. Read More @ LifeNews.com 
A California pastor, Jack Hibbs of Calvary Chapel Chino Hills, is speaking up against a move by the state to force churches to fund abortions and he says he will gladly go to jail before complying with the abortion mandate. But churches in California are refusing to comply with the law. Instead, they’re working with the pro-life legal group Alliance Defending Freedom to file suit against the state. And one church leader is willing to defy the state. Read More: 
The Planned Parenthood facility where abortion center manager-turned pro-life advocate Abby Johnson worked is now a functioning pro-life pregnancy center. Hope Pregnancy Centers of Brazos Valley purchased the Bryan, Texas Planned Parenthood building last year after the abortion center closed. Read More 
State legislators in Colorado today held a hearing concerning a Planned Parenthood abortion clinic that was caught in an expose’ video selling aborted babies. While legislators attended the hearing along with pro-life groups looking to expose the abortion business, representatives from Planned Parenthood refused to attend. Read More
During a press conference yesterday, Speaker Paul Ryan called on the Senate to pass a House-approved reconciliation bill that would de-fund the Planned Parenthood abortion business in the wake of the scandal showing it selling aborted baby body parts. Read More 
It isn’t every day that liberal Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg likes something that’s pro-life. But a video of New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie talking about his pro-life stance caught the young CEO’s eye, according to The Blaze. “Every life is precious,” Christie said during a townhall event last week that was captured on video by The Huffington Post. “Every life is an individual gift from God.” Read More 
